Employee Discipline
Page Contents
- Federal
- Summary
- Treat Employee Discipline as an Opportunity
- Investigating Employee Behavior
- Investigative Process
- Interplay Among Departments
- Degree of Investigation Required
- Keeping Investigations Confidential
- Confidentiality Policies and NLRA Concerns
- Witness Coordination
- Document Coordination
- Employer Searches and Employee Privacy
- Testing
- Lie Detector Tests
- Honesty Tests
- Drug Testing
- Recordkeeping
- Resolving Disciplinary Issues Informally
- Alternatives to Discipline
- Leniency or Amnesty Plans
- Additional Training Opportunities
- Counseling
- Accommodations and Alternate Work Arrangements
- Referrals to Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
- The Process of Discipline
- Establishing Rules of Conduct
- Establishing Discipline Policies
- Communicating Expectations for Workplace Conduct
- Expectations for Conduct Outside of Work
- Disciplining Employees With Criminal Histories or Pending Proceedings
- Disciplining Employees in Garnishment or Bankruptcy Proceedings
- Lawful Behaviors Outside of Work
- Progressive Discipline
- Who Disciplines?
- Including HR in the Disciplinary Process
- Special Considerations in Labor Environments
- Consistent Discipline Process Among Supervisors
- Procedures
- Documentation
- Types of Discipline
- Counseling
- Oral Warning
- Written Reprimand
- Demotion
- Suspension
- Termination
- The Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)
- Conducting the Disciplinary Meeting
- Recording Meetings
- Exceptions to Progressive Discipline
- Discipline of Probationary Employees
- Discipline of Employees in Protected Classes
- Disciplining Employees Who Have Engaged in Protected Activities
- Discipline Considerations
- Defamation Avoidance
- False Imprisonment
- Computer Fraud and Abuse Act
- Specific Discipline Situations
- Attendance
- Tracking Employee Attendance
- Attendance Policies
- Inclement Weather, Disasters and Business Interruptions
- Attendance and Military Leave
- Attendance and the Family and Medical Leave Act
- Attendance and Disability
- Workplace Theft
- Employee Theft of Intellectual Property
- Policy on Confidential Information and Trade Secrets
- Policy on Employer Ownership of Intellectual Property
- Nondisclosure Agreements (NDAs)
- Noncompetition Agreements
- Nonsolicitation Agreements
- Government Employees
- Duty of Loyalty
- Code of Ethics
- Employee Surveillance Considerations
- Sabotage
- Suspected Workplace Theft
- Disciplining Employees With Drug and Alcohol Addictions
- Alternatives to Disciplining Substance Abusers
- Employee Assistance Program (EAP)
- Last Chance Agreement
- Drug-Free Workplace Act Requirements
- The ADA and Employees With Substance Abuse Problems
- Performance and Conduct Standards for Employees With Substance Abuse Problems
- Testing Employees for Alcohol and Drug Use
- Disciplining Employees With Substance Abuse Problems
- Whistleblower Protections
- Internal Strategies
- Role of Workplace Culture or Policies
- Employer Attitude Toward Whistleblowers
- Handling Complaint Resolution
- Handling the Internal Complaint
- Follow Internal Policies and Procedures
- Maintain Confidentiality
- Consult Outside Counsel
- Protecting Internal Whistleblowers from Retaliation
- Updating Complainants
- Handling External Investigations and Litigation
- OSHA Enforcement of Statutes
- Federal Whistleblower Laws Not Enforced by OSHA
- Disciplining a Whistleblower: Retaliatory or Not?
- Potential Penalties
- Future Developments
- Additional Resources
Federal
Authors: Wayne D. Garris and Christine Zebrowski, Overbrook Law LLC
Summary
- When used appropriately, employee discipline can improve communication with employees and foster positive outcomes. See Treat Discipline as an Opportunity.
- Failure to adequately discipline employees leads to low overall morale and to a greater risk of liability. See Treat Discipline as an Opportunity.
- Employers should explore alternatives to discipline in order to improve performance or curtail unacceptable employee behavior. See Alternatives to Discipline.
- Employers should implement policies and procedures that enforce rules of conduct, communicate those policies to employees and apply disciplinary procedures uniformly. See The Process of Discipline.
- Employers should communicate their expectations for conduct while employees are on duty, off duty and on the premises. See Communicating Expectations for Workplace Conduct.
- Common discipline problems include poor attendance, substance abuse and workplace theft. See Specific Discipline Situations.
- Attendance policies can be enforced through a system of excused and unexcused absences or no fault policies in which all absences are counted against the employee. See Attendance Policies.
- An adequate attendance policy should require employees to notify their employers of absences, designate a person to receive absence notification, provide disciplinary consequences for failure to comply with policy and address absence during special events outside of work, including training programs. See Attendance Policies.
- Employers should promptly discipline instances of workplace theft, which include unauthorized taking of employer property, sabotage, embezzlement, trade secret theft and cyber slacking. See Specific Discipline Situations; Workplace Theft.
- When disciplining employees with substance abuse problems, employers should explore alternatives to discipline. In addition, employers should consider any privacy protections or antidiscrimination prohibitions when implementing an employee drug testing program. See Specific Discipline Situations; Disciplining Employees With Substance Abuse Problems.
- Whistleblowing occurs when an employee in a government agency or a private company discloses information or makes a complaint of mismanagement, corruption or wrongdoing. Employers should use extreme caution when disciplining employee whistleblowers. See Specific Discipline Situations; Whistleblower Protections.
State Requirements
The following states have additional requirements for this topic under applicable state law.
- Alabama
- Alaska
- Arizona
- Arkansas
- California
- Colorado
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- District of Columbia
- Florida
- Georgia
- Hawaii
- Idaho
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Louisiana
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- Montana
- Nebraska
- Nevada
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New Mexico
- New York
- North Carolina
- North Dakota
- Ohio
- Oklahoma
- Oregon
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- South Dakota
- Tennessee
- Texas
- Utah
- Vermont
- Virginia
- Washington
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
- Wyoming