HR Support on Exempt and Non-Exempt Employee Classification

Editor's Note: One of the trickiest compliance challenges for HR.

Michael CardmanOverview: The Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) was written in 1938, at a time when manufacturing and agriculture dominated the American economy. The law's structure for employee classification as exempt or nonexempt from minimum wage laws and overtime requirements reflects that simpler time. Although it has been updated periodically in the decades since, the FLSA's classification scheme is often difficult to apply to more modern service- and information-related jobs.

One type of employee that has proven especially difficult to fit into the employee classification structure – and has also been the plaintiff in hundreds of lawsuits – is managers. Today's lean, flexible workplace often necessitates that managers pitch in and perform nonexempt work, rather than stand around with a clipboard in hand directing other employees. The more nonexempt work they do, the more likely it is they need to be paid overtime.

Complicating matters is the fact that employees' job duties change frequently. Employers often make the mistake of classifying all employees with a particular job title as exempt. When changes in the workplace necessitate changes in an employee's job duties, that classification can be jeopardized. HR is well-positioned to stay on top of these changes, and must remember that FLSA classification is an ongoing challenge, not a one-time task.

In addition, it's important that employers follow state requirements regarding employee classification.

Trends: The two-headed dragon of employee lawsuits and government enforcement continues to make FLSA classification a key concern for HR. Many lawsuits have been collective actions, in which hundreds and sometimes even thousands of similarly situated employees sue as a group. The standard for certifying these collective actions is relatively lenient compared to other employment laws, and for many years, most courts allowed them to proceed. Recently, the pendulum appears to be swinging in the other direction, with more and more courts taking a more stringent stance on whether employees truly are similar enough to sue as a group.

Michael Cardman, Legal Editor

Latest items in Employee Classification

  • Does an employer have to pay interns?

    Type:
    FAQs

  • Terms of Employment

    Type:
    Employment Law Manual

    The terms and conditions that govern the employment relationship are typically governed by federal and state employment laws, including antidiscrimination laws. This section helps HR professionals avoid discriminating on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, pregnancy, national origin, age, disability, genetic information and veteran status throughout the employment relationship.

  • Retail Resource Center for HR

    Date:
    01 May 2013
    Type:
    Editor's Choice

    XpertHR's Retail Resource Center for HR helps retail employers handle their most vexing employment issues by bringing relevant resources together in one place for easy access.

  • Unusual Compensation Plan Did Not Invalidate FLSA Exemption, 3rd Circuit Rules

    Date:
    29 April 2013
    Type:
    News

    An employer may prorate the base pay of a salaried employee without forfeiting the employee's exemption from the overtime requirements of the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA), as long as it covers the shortfall with additional premium compensation, the 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals held in Sander v. Light Action.

  • New Content Added on Unpaid Internships

    Date:
    29 April 2013
    Type:
    Editor's Choice

    A new Legal Insight and a new How To about unpaid internships under the Fair Labor Standards Act have been added to XpertHR.

  • How to Structure an Unpaid Internship or Training Program

    Type:
    How To

    The US Department of Labor will consider interns and trainees to be employees entitled to the minimum wage and overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) unless specific criteria are met. Follow these steps to increase the likelihood that interns or trainees are not employees.

  • Date:
    24 April 2013
    Type:
    Legal Insight

    Unpaid internships or training programs can result in a lawsuit for back wages and overtime under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) unless specific criteria are satisfied. This Legal Insight analyzes standards established by the US Department of Labor and by the federal courts in an effort to guide employers that may wish to establish unpaid internships or training programs.

  • Illinois Employee Classification Act of 2008 Poster

    Type:
    Policies and Documents

    The Illinois Employee Classification Act of 2008 poster, mandated by the Illinois Department of Labor, is required for all construction contractors utilizing independent contractors.

  • High-Tech/Software and Communications Resource Center for HR: Wage and Hour

    Date:
    16 April 2013
    Type:
    Editor's Choice

    XpertHR's High-Tech Resource Center for HR: Wage and Hour helps high-tech employers handle their most challenging employment issues by bringing relevant resources together in one place for easy access.

  • White House Looking to Increase Enforcement of FLSA and FMLA

    Date:
    11 April 2013
    Type:
    News

    President Obama also is seeking additional funding for investigations of independent contractor misclassifications and for a new integrated enforcement and case management system.